Set your assumptions
Example values are prefilled. Replace them with your own assumptions.
Shared links include your inputs. Use example values if you do not want to disclose your numbers.
Your scenario
Default results are illustrative; changes recalculate immediately.
Ending balance difference: B minus A
$180,249- Option A: ending balance
- $774,431
- Option B: ending balance
- $954,680
- A: modeled fees charged
- $87,980
- B: modeled fees charged
- $5,055
- A: return effect of fees vs zero-fee case
- $102,928
- B: return effect of fees vs zero-fee case
- $5,604
- A: unpaid account/adviser charges
- $0
- B: unpaid account/adviser charges
- $0
After 30 years, Option B minus Option A is $180,249. A positive difference favors B’s ending balance under identical gross returns and deposits. Modeled fees charged are separated from the return effect of those deductions; return effects may be negative when returns are negative. This is a cost illustration, not a comparison of service quality or a forecast of fund performance.
Balances and cumulative modeled fees
The zero-fee path is an illustration, not an available product. Contributions, gross return and horizon are the same. Dollar amounts are nominal; charges are not inflation-adjusted.
| Year | A: balance | B: balance | Zero-fee balance | A: fees charged | B: fees charged |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Year 0 | $50,000 | $50,000 | $50,000 | $0 | $0 |
| Year 1 | $59,163 | $59,664 | $59,690 | $511 | $26 |
| Year 2 | $68,876 | $69,999 | $70,059 | $1,111 | $56 |
| Year 3 | $79,172 | $81,053 | $81,153 | $1,805 | $91 |
| Year 4 | $90,086 | $92,875 | $93,024 | $2,599 | $132 |
| Year 5 | $101,654 | $105,519 | $105,726 | $3,499 | $178 |
| Year 6 | $113,917 | $119,041 | $119,316 | $4,511 | $230 |
| Year 7 | $126,915 | $133,503 | $133,859 | $5,642 | $290 |
| Year 8 | $140,693 | $148,970 | $149,419 | $6,899 | $356 |
| Year 9 | $155,298 | $165,513 | $166,068 | $8,290 | $429 |
| Year 10 | $170,779 | $183,205 | $183,883 | $9,822 | $511 |
| Year 11 | $187,189 | $202,126 | $202,945 | $11,504 | $601 |
| Year 12 | $204,584 | $222,363 | $223,342 | $13,346 | $700 |
| Year 13 | $223,022 | $244,006 | $245,166 | $15,356 | $809 |
| Year 14 | $242,567 | $267,153 | $268,518 | $17,544 | $929 |
| Year 15 | $263,284 | $291,909 | $293,504 | $19,923 | $1,060 |
| Year 16 | $285,244 | $318,385 | $320,239 | $22,502 | $1,203 |
| Year 17 | $308,522 | $346,702 | $348,846 | $25,294 | $1,358 |
| Year 18 | $333,197 | $376,986 | $379,456 | $28,312 | $1,528 |
| Year 19 | $359,352 | $409,376 | $412,208 | $31,569 | $1,712 |
| Year 20 | $387,076 | $444,016 | $447,252 | $35,079 | $1,912 |
| Year 21 | $416,464 | $481,064 | $484,750 | $38,859 | $2,128 |
| Year 22 | $447,615 | $520,687 | $524,873 | $42,923 | $2,363 |
| Year 23 | $480,635 | $563,063 | $567,804 | $47,290 | $2,616 |
| Year 24 | $515,637 | $608,385 | $613,741 | $51,976 | $2,891 |
| Year 25 | $552,738 | $656,857 | $662,893 | $57,002 | $3,187 |
| Year 26 | $592,066 | $708,697 | $715,485 | $62,388 | $3,507 |
| Year 27 | $633,753 | $764,140 | $771,759 | $68,155 | $3,852 |
| Year 28 | $677,941 | $823,437 | $831,973 | $74,326 | $4,223 |
| Year 29 | $724,781 | $886,855 | $896,401 | $80,926 | $4,624 |
| Year 30 | $774,431 | $954,680 | $965,339 | $87,980 | $5,055 |
Separate fee deductions from their compounding effect
Fund costs are approximated by subtracting the annual expense ratio from the annual gross return, then converting that net annual return to a monthly factor: (1 + gross return − expense ratio)1/12 − 1. This preserves the original calculator’s fund-only growth assumption. The gap between gross and net monthly growth is recorded as modeled fund cost.
Each month, a separate adviser fee is opening balance × annual adviser rate ÷ 12, and a flat charge is annual fixed fee ÷ 12. After net fund growth and the month-end deposit, these charges are deducted from available assets. Any amount beyond available assets is reported as unpaid; the portfolio cannot go below zero.
Ending balance gap versus no fees = modeled fees charged + return effect of those fees. The return effect includes growth lost on past deductions; it can be negative under negative returns. It is not another fee charged by the provider. The comparison does not convert the gap into a predicted number of lost retirement years.
Worked example with the default assumptions
These are illustrative defaults, not recommended budgets, benefit amounts, returns or loan offers. Inputs and results below are generated from the same model as the live calculator.
| Default assumption | Value |
|---|---|
| Shared assumptions: Starting portfolio ($) | 50000 |
| Shared assumptions: Monthly deposit before account fees ($) | 500 |
| Shared assumptions: Years invested | 30 |
| Shared assumptions: Annual gross return before all fees (%) | 7 |
| Option A: A: fund expense ratio (%) | 1 |
| Option A: A: separate adviser fee (%/year) | 0 |
| Option A: A: fixed account/adviser fee ($/year) | 0 |
| Option B: B: fund expense ratio (%) | 0.05 |
| Option B: B: separate adviser fee (%/year) | 0 |
| Option B: B: fixed account/adviser fee ($/year) | 0 |
| Default result | Value |
|---|---|
| Ending balance difference: B minus A | $180,249 |
| Option A: ending balance | $774,431 |
| Option B: ending balance | $954,680 |
| A: modeled fees charged | $87,980 |
| B: modeled fees charged | $5,055 |
| A: return effect of fees vs zero-fee case | $102,928 |
| B: return effect of fees vs zero-fee case | $5,604 |
| A: unpaid account/adviser charges | $0 |
| B: unpaid account/adviser charges | $0 |
Read the fee schedule before combining charges
A fund expense ratio, an adviser’s percentage fee and a fixed subscription can coexist. Use the fund prospectus, account disclosures and adviser fee schedule to identify which charges are additional. If a quoted fee already includes another charge, do not add it twice. SEC investor guidance explains both product-level and account-level expenses.
To compare a flat-fee adviser with an assets-based adviser, keep the fund ratio the same, put the percentage in one option and the annual flat amount in the other. The flat fee here is paid from the modeled portfolio in equal monthly amounts. If you pay it from wages, that is a different cash-flow assumption.
Costs do not measure all the value of advice
Actual funds accrue expenses differently, and advisers can bill quarterly, use tiered rates or charge minimums. These are monthly planning approximations, not reconstructions of statements. Taxes, trading costs, sales loads, bid-ask spreads, performance fees, cash holdings and different investment strategies are excluded.
Equal gross returns isolate cost differences; they do not predict that two products will earn identical returns. Review the services, risk and investments as well as costs. For long-term purchasing power and retirement withdrawals, use the linked calculators with consistent assumptions.
Frequently asked questions
Is the balance difference the total fee bill?
No. It includes the effect of fees on subsequent returns. The page separately reports modeled fees charged and their return effect against a zero-fee illustration.
Can I compare flat fees with a percentage adviser fee?
Yes. Enter the separate adviser percentage in one option and a fixed annual fee in the other. Both are paid monthly from portfolio assets in this model.
Will old shared scenarios still work?
The original start, monthly, years, ret, yourFee and idxFee inputs remain supported. New adviser and flat charges default to zero, preserving the fund-only model.
Sources & model notes
- SEC Investor.gov: how fees and expenses affect a portfolio
- SEC Investor.gov: fund expense ratios and other charges
Calculator, formulas and examples by FinancialDepth, checked November 19, 2026. Sources explain the underlying account or product rules; numerical projections come from the assumptions shown on this page. See our methodology and limitations.
Continue planning
- Stress-test withdrawals after fees
- Estimate a financial independence target
- Compare purchasing power of income
Explore all financial calculators.