FinancialDepth
Debt & mortgage

Mortgage payoff vs invest calculator

Use the same dollars and the same finish line. Compare paying extra on your mortgage with investing, including what happens after the loan is paid off.

Updated November 7, 2026Transparent assumptionsEducational estimate
01

Set your assumptions

Example values are prefilled. Replace them with your own assumptions.

Fixed note rate, not APR. Monthly interest is this rate divided by 12.
Prepay-first applies this to principal; invest-extra invests it immediately.
Your assumption after fees and tax drag. Returns may be negative.
Both paths use this same horizon, even if a mortgage pays off earlier.

Shared links include your inputs. Use example values if you do not want to disclose your numbers.

02

Your scenario

Default results are illustrative; changes recalculate immediately.

Difference at the chosen horizon

$24,252
Higher modeled financial position
Invest-extra path
Scheduled monthly principal + interest
$1,580.17
Equal monthly budget in both paths
$2,330.17
Prepay-first loan payoff
Month 162
Prepay first: investments minus debt
$852,837
Invest extra: investments minus debt
$877,089
Equivalent effective annual mortgage rate
6.7%

At month 360, compare investments minus remaining mortgage debt. Both paths use $2,330.17 each month and $0 at the start. Freed payments are invested, including leftover cash in the payoff month. Home value is excluded equally. Return assumptions are not forecasts.

Where the money is at the same point in time

Positive final-column values favor investing the extra cash under these assumptions. Negative values favor prepaying first. Home value is identical and omitted; these are not complete net-worth totals.

MonthPrepay: investmentsPrepay: debtInvest: investmentsInvest: debtInvest minus prepay
0$0$250,000$0$250,000$0
12$0$237,933$9,285$247,206$12
24$0$225,057$19,220$244,224$53
36$0$211,319$29,851$241,043$127
48$0$196,661$41,226$237,649$238
60$0$181,022$53,397$234,027$391
72$0$164,335$66,420$230,163$592
84$0$146,531$80,355$226,041$844
96$0$127,534$95,265$221,642$1,157
108$0$107,265$111,218$216,948$1,535
120$0$85,638$128,289$211,940$1,986
132$0$62,563$146,554$206,597$2,520
144$0$37,943$166,098$200,896$3,145
156$0$11,673$187,010$194,813$3,871
168$16,367$0$209,386$188,323$4,697
180$46,360$0$233,329$181,398$5,570
192$78,454$0$258,947$174,009$6,484
204$112,794$0$286,358$166,126$7,439
216$149,538$0$315,689$157,714$8,437
228$188,853$0$347,072$148,739$9,479
240$230,921$0$380,652$139,163$10,568
252$275,934$0$416,583$128,946$11,703
264$324,098$0$455,029$118,044$12,887
276$375,633$0$496,166$106,413$14,121
288$430,775$0$540,183$94,002$15,406
300$489,778$0$587,281$80,760$16,743
312$552,910$0$637,676$66,632$18,134
324$620,462$0$691,599$51,557$19,580
336$692,743$0$749,296$35,473$21,081
348$770,083$0$811,032$18,311$22,638
360$852,837$0$877,089$0$24,252

Give both paths the same budget

The monthly budget is the scheduled principal-and-interest payment plus the extra amount. In the prepay-first path, the lump sum reduces principal immediately and the monthly extra also pays down debt. When the mortgage is cleared, the full budget goes into investments. Any unused cash in the final loan-payment month is invested that month.

In the invest-extra path, the lump sum is invested at the start, the scheduled mortgage payment continues and the monthly extra is invested at month end. Once that loan also ends, its full monthly budget goes into investments. A lump sum larger than the debt is capped at the balance in the prepay path and the remainder is invested immediately.

Investments grow before each month-end deposit at (1 + net annual return)1/12. Mortgage interest is opening principal times note rate / 12. Each final payment is capped at the outstanding balance plus that month’s interest. Calculations use unrounded payments internally; lenders may round differently.

Worked example with the default inputs

These are illustrative defaults, not suggested benefits, returns or a personal recommendation. The results below use the same monthly model as the interactive comparison.

Example inputValue
Current mortgage balance ($)250000
Annual mortgage note rate (%)6.5
Months remaining on loan360
Cash available now ($)0
Extra monthly budget ($)750
Net effective annual investment return (%)7
Compare after this many months360
Example outputResult
Difference at the chosen horizon$24,252
Higher modeled financial positionInvest-extra path
Scheduled monthly principal + interest$1,580.17
Equal monthly budget in both paths$2,330.17
Prepay-first loan payoffMonth 162
Invest extra: investments minus debt$877,089
Prepay first: investments minus debt$852,837
Equivalent effective annual mortgage rate6.7%

How sensitive is the comparison to returns?

Change only the net investment return by two percentage points either way, bounded by the input limits. All cash flows and the comparison horizon remain the same.

Net annual returnPrepay: investments − debtInvest: investments − debtInvest minus prepay
5%$712,097$611,532-$100,565
7%$852,837$877,089$24,252
9%$1,025,598$1,276,585$250,987

Compare assets minus debt, not interest saved alone

At a horizon before the original loan ends, one path may still owe more on the house. Comparing only the investment accounts hides that difference. This tool subtracts remaining mortgage debt from each investment balance. The home itself is omitted because its value is the same in both scenarios.

Interest saved is also not an investment account balance. Comparing an interest-savings total at an early payoff date with investments after 30 years uses different finish lines. The table here compares identical months and assumes you actually invest the freed payments.

The equivalent effective annual mortgage rate is (1 + note rate / 12)12 − 1. Under the simplified model, that is the investment return where the paths tie. It differs from the quoted note rate because the investment input is an effective annual return. Fees, deductions and taxes can change the real-world comparison.

A higher projected balance does not settle the decision

Investment returns are uncertain, while principal paid into the home is less liquid. This model assumes a fixed loan, reliable payments and a constant net investment return. It excludes recasting, refinancing, mortgage-interest deductions, prepayment penalties and the cost of accessing home equity. Property tax, insurance, maintenance and HOA costs continue after payoff and are outside both budgets.

Use the sensitivity comparison to see what happens at a return two percentage points lower or higher. Those are scenarios, not probabilities. For a lump sum paid at a later date or a lower required payment after recasting, use the mortgage lump sum calculator.

Frequently asked questions

What happens to payments after the mortgage is paid off?

The full monthly budget is invested. Leftover cash in the last payment month is invested too, so both strategies use equal cash flows.

Why is my 6.5% mortgage not exactly equivalent to a 6.5% annual investment return?

Mortgage interest here uses the note rate divided by 12. The investment input is an effective annual return. Compounding the monthly mortgage rate for 12 months gives the comparable annual rate.

Sources & model notes

Calculator, formulas and examples by FinancialDepth, checked November 7, 2026. Sources explain the underlying account or product rules; numerical projections come from the assumptions shown on this page. See our methodology and limitations.

Continue planning

Explore all financial calculators.