FinancialDepth
Retirement

Pension lump sum vs monthly calculator

Put both pension offers on the same timeline. Compare the payment stream, its present value and how long a lump sum could fund the same income.

Updated November 7, 2026Transparent assumptionsEducational estimate
01

Set your assumptions

Example values are prefilled. Replace them with your own assumptions.

Use the actual quoted payout option, including any survivor election.
This comparison assumes the cash and pension are available at the same starting date.
Use 0 for a fixed pension with no cost-of-living increase.
Used only to value the pension cash flows at the starting date.
A constant effective return after investment fees; use a consistent tax basis for both offers.
Used to show the purchasing power of the monthly pension.

Shared links include your inputs. Use example values if you do not want to disclose your numbers.

02

Your scenario

Default results are illustrative; changes recalculate immediately.

Present value of pension payments

$633,845
Undiscounted catch-up age
78y 11m
Discounted catch-up age
85y 2m
First-year payout / lump sum
7.2%
Lump-sum account at horizon
$0
First insufficient account payment
85y 2m
Final monthly pension in start-date dollars
$1,430.23

Both offers start at age 65. Pension payments are valued at a 4% discount rate. The separate lump-sum account earns an assumed 4% net return and funds the same monthly cash flows. The annual payout ratio includes return of capital; it is not investment yield.

Pension income and the separate lump-sum account

The account column assumes the lump sum funds exactly the same monthly income as the pension. Cumulative pension is income received, not an account balance. Unfunded income is cumulative nominal shortfall.

AgePension receivedPension present valueAccount remainingUnfunded incomeMonthly pension: real
66$36,000$35,246$483,345$0$2,926.83
67$72,000$69,135$466,023$0$2,855.44
68$108,000$101,722$448,009$0$2,785.80
69$144,000$133,055$429,274$0$2,717.85
70$180,000$163,183$409,789$0$2,651.56
71$216,000$192,152$389,526$0$2,586.89
72$252,000$220,007$368,451$0$2,523.80
73$288,000$246,791$346,534$0$2,462.24
74$324,000$272,545$323,740$0$2,402.19
75$360,000$297,308$300,034$0$2,343.60
76$396,000$321,118$275,380$0$2,286.43
77$432,000$344,013$249,740$0$2,230.67
78$468,000$366,027$223,075$0$2,176.26
79$504,000$387,195$195,342$0$2,123.18
80$540,000$407,548$166,501$0$2,071.40
81$576,000$427,119$136,505$0$2,020.87
82$612,000$445,937$105,310$0$1,971.59
83$648,000$464,031$72,867$0$1,923.50
84$684,000$481,429$39,127$0$1,876.58
85$720,000$498,158$4,036$0$1,830.81
86$756,000$514,243$0$31,947$1,786.16
87$792,000$529,710$0$67,947$1,742.59
88$828,000$544,582$0$103,947$1,700.09
89$864,000$558,882$0$139,947$1,658.63
90$900,000$572,632$0$175,947$1,618.17
91$936,000$585,854$0$211,947$1,578.70
92$972,000$598,566$0$247,947$1,540.20
93$1,008,000$610,790$0$283,947$1,502.63
94$1,044,000$622,544$0$319,947$1,465.98
95$1,080,000$633,845$0$355,947$1,430.23

Compare offers on a common basis

Enter the pension quote for the payment option you would actually choose. A single-life quote and a joint-and-survivor quote can have different monthly payments. Ask the plan administrator about payment dates, increases, survivor provisions and any guarantee period. This model assumes both offers begin together; it does not price a deferred pension or assign probabilities to survival.

Monthly payments occur at month end. The annual increase applies after every 12 payments. Present value adds each payment divided by (1 + discount rate)month / 12. The undiscounted catch-up age is when payments received first equal the lump sum. The discounted version asks when their start-date value reaches that amount.

The separate account starts with the lump sum, grows at (1 + net annual return)1/12 each month and then pays the same income as the pension. Withdrawals stop at the available balance; unpaid amounts accumulate as a shortfall. Returns remain constant in this scenario, so it does not simulate a market downturn or sequence risk.

Worked example with the default inputs

These are illustrative defaults, not suggested benefits, returns or a personal recommendation. The results below use the same monthly model as the interactive comparison.

Example inputValue
Lump-sum offer ($)500000
Starting monthly pension ($)3000
Age when both offers begin65
Compare through age95
Annual pension increase (%)0
Annual discount rate (%)4
Lump-sum net annual return (%)4
Annual inflation (%)2.5
Example outputResult
Present value of pension payments$633,845
Undiscounted catch-up age78y 11m
Discounted catch-up age85y 2m
First-year payout / lump sum7.2%
Lump-sum account at horizon$0
First insufficient account payment85y 2m
Final monthly pension in start-date dollars$1,430.23

A pension payout ratio is not an investment yield

Annual pension divided by the lump sum is a cash payout ratio. It includes the economic return of capital and may end at death under the chosen contract. It is not directly comparable with the yield on an account whose principal remains yours. Read the present-value comparison together with the account drawdown and the actual survivor terms.

The horizon is a scenario, not an estimate of your lifespan. A lifetime pension may continue beyond it, while an investment account can be depleted before it. Conversely, an account may leave assets to heirs. This tool does not calculate those rights or the value of mortality pooling.

Taxes, inflation and plan terms can change the choice

Use consistent pre-tax or after-tax amounts. The calculator does not determine rollover eligibility, withholding, withdrawal tax or the applicable pension guarantee. A rollover is not automatically tax-free spending money. Confirm the treatment of each offer before relying on an after-tax comparison.

The real monthly income column divides the last payment in each year by cumulative inflation at that year end. Even if a fixed pension never changes in dollars, its purchasing power can decline. The CFPB’s pension guide discusses the transfer of investment and longevity risk when accepting a lump sum. Use the actual plan documents for the terms that apply to you.

Frequently asked questions

Does a 7.2% pension payout mean a 7.2% investment return?

No. Annual payments divided by a lump sum is a payout ratio, which can include return of capital. It does not preserve principal or value survivor provisions.

Why can the account run short while the pension keeps paying?

The account has a finite balance and earns only the return you assume. Pension payments follow the plan’s contract. This model does not establish the plan’s ability to pay or its guarantee coverage.

Sources & model notes

Calculator, formulas and examples by FinancialDepth, checked November 7, 2026. Sources explain the underlying account or product rules; numerical projections come from the assumptions shown on this page. See our methodology and limitations.

Continue planning

Explore all financial calculators.